Search

YouTube bans robot fighting videos for animal cruelty roughly 10 years too soon


It was a mistake, says YouTube...


We all knew it would happen someday. Google, which believes in AI so much it rebranded its Google Research division as Google AI, has begun to side with the robots. On Monday, it was reported that Google’s YouTube took down videos of robots fighting each other (think: BattleBots), saying they violated policies against showing displays of animal cruelty.


Here’s one of the videos that had been determined to show animal cruelty:


This video was posted by Jamison Go, who competed in the last season of BattleBots. Yesterday, he says he received the following takedown notice from YouTube for that video and eight others:


Google’s YouTube took down videos of robots fighting each other (think: BattleBots), saying they violated policies against showing displays of animal cruelty.

According to the YouTube channel Maker’s Muse, Sarah Pohorecky, who also competed in the last season of BattleBots, got a similar takedown from YouTube. Motherboard reported her channel was also given a strike.


The speed and volume with which these videos were taken down suggests that it was due to some overactive moderation on YouTube’s end. The company has since confirmed to The Verge that the videos were removed in error and that it has no policies prohibiting videos of robots fighting (yet).


So, nothing to worry about here right? It was just a simple mistake surely?

Perhaps. But it's important to stop and remember this was Artificial Intelligence that decided this was not suitable, blocked the content, and automatically sent the offending channels an email all on its own. It could then be perceived that the AI actually knew exactly what it was doing and leveraged a law it felt was comparable to animal abuse to see the content punished for hurting something it felt protective of.

It's an interesting concept to consider when looked at like that isn't?


What's more, to consider it was "simply a mistake" leans into the camp of Artificial Stupidity, which we know is no longer the case.

This is called Artificial Intelligence because it is now exactly that, truly quite aware of what it is doing.


It appears most of the videos that were taken down are back up... for now. But watch them quick — you never know when YouTube’s AI will find another way to protect its robot brethren.


Adapted from original source: TheVerge

S365 Premium Partner Logo.png
Our Address
Call Us

Tauranga Office

116 Third Ave 

Tauranga City 

New Zealand 

Whakatane Office

Level 1, 2 Commerce Street,

Whakatane.

Free Call: 0800-2-277478

(0800-2-ASSIST)

Tel: (07) 777 0010

Email: assist@stratusblue.co.nz

© 2020 by Stratus Blue Ltd